Hot knife cutting & welding
The benefits of hot knife cutting and welding as preparation for easy seam sewing for DIY backpacking tents and gear are discussed.
Background
In another post on making modular tent patterns for pyramid tents, I described the great benefits of hot cutting as opposed to the use of scissors. I started this evolution of hot cutting with a soldering iron as shown below.
During the above post, I introduced the use of hot knife cutting. It was a great improvement on using a soldering iron which in itself was a big improvement on scissors. The benefits of hot knife cutting for DIY cutting and welding are so great that I thought that it deserved the prominence of a post of its own.
There are so many similar hot knife cutters available online. Many are designed for use with 110V so my choice was more limited because I needed a 240V model with an Australian standard plug. There are so many blades to choose from. I chose the KS Eagle Hot Cutter with the ‘arc-style’ blade. The blade shown has proven to be very versatile and as is my usual wont, I have modified it a little to suit my particular tasks better (described later).
I was delighted with the performance of the knife. As an example, for 58 gsm polyester fabric, it requires 5-15 seconds to heat to a magically smooth cutting temperature. The 15 seconds is for a cold start and 5 or more seconds for a restart of an already hot cutter. During extra-long cuts, the trigger can easily be pulsed on and off to prevent overheating (excessive smoking) while maintaining a smooth cutting temperature (dull red cutter blade).
“I often muck around with a sewing machine making things using technical fabrics. These are mainly (but not exclusivel) for selfish but noble pursuits like sailing, fishing, backpacking and skiing. Often in delightful combination. The hot knife cutter is one of those tools that I should have had long ago. At about $80 it has paid for itself in just a few moths.
I should also share with you that my new ‘sewing-high’ is somewhat boosted by other factors including Covid lockdowns and other little sewing breakthoughs. I think I can say that for a ‘crap sewer’ I have achieved a unique mastery of a very efficient lay flat seam that was taught to me by my mum. Silicone rubber as a sewable glue (instead of pins) to tack complex and long seams together was another breakthrough. Now hot cutting/melting/welding is another innovative step forward for this DIY tinkerer. I hope the ideas may advance your tinkering.”
Mothy The Elder
The benefits of hot knife cutting for sewn seam preparation
- The blade glides smoothly through the fabric without disturbing the lay of the fabric.
- When guided by a straight edge it can easily make perfectly straight cuts with minimal marking out.
- The edges of the cut fabric do not fray to make a mess and tangle in the sewing machine and in the new Dyson.
- Seams can be narrower because of the lack of fraying and the new strength of the fused fabric edge.
- Seams can be simpler if fabric rolling is not required to hide and protect the fabric edges that would otherwise fray if cut with scissors.
- Lastly, the hot cutting can also weld multiple fabric laminates together while cutting and this can make the subsequent sewing much easier or in some applications make sewing unnecessary.
Other benefits of hot knife cutting
- Cuts seat-belt webbings and ‘tugboat ropes’ like butter.
- Easily cuts PET and other plastic bottles and thick plastic drums.
- Can soften and round cut plastic edges.
- Does edge to edge welding of PET bottle plastic.
- Acts as a hot scraper to remove synthetic fabric that is stuck to silicone rubber or other heat resistant surfaces.
Using the hot knife cutting/welding as preparation for easy seam sewing
Hot knife cutting/welding. When preparing to sew two layers of fabric together to form a sewn seam, crap sewers like me, need to pin the two layers of fabric together to make the seam easier to sew. This is particularly important when a bias grain edge must be sewn to a straight grain edge. The unwanted creep of the bias grain edge is often difficult to manage, particularly with fine and slippery synthetic technical fabrics.
The hot knife cutting (or trimming) of two pieces of fabric can weld them together. Then with the edges welded together the subsequent seam sewing is made very easy with no risk of fabric creep for the crap sewer. Because of the precision and lack of fraying the seams can be simpler or narrower than they may otherwise be.
Single stitch simple seams. For medium strength seams, a single row of stitches without seam rolling will suffice as there will be no ugly fraying edge to protect or hide for aesthetic reasons.
As an example, simple storage bags with drawcord hems are so simple to make this way. A simply sewn drawcord seam can be sewn on a width of fabric (after hot cutting) and then it can be folded over to form multiple suitable sized bags before hot cutting/welding a side and bottom seams. Once welded together the sewing can be very easy and simple.
Single stitch rolled seams. Alternatively, the above seam can first be easily rolled and stitched through the four layers. This makes a plumper and stronger seam that is more resistant to tensile stretch/breakage (in use) and greatly improves the longitudinal seam strength.
Single stitch double rolled seams. The seam as described above can be rolled a second time before stitching. “Just like the traditional seam that we would do if we were protecting/hiding a fraying scissor cut edge.” This gives the seam six layers of thickness, more plumpness and greater stretch strength. “With edge welding, the seam is almost as easy to make as the single rolled seam and managing a bias-cut edge is made trouble-free because the two layers behave like one.”
Rolled and lay-flat/double-stitched seam with or without embedded tie-outs. This seam can easily be formed by hot cutting/welding then rolling and stitching. Tent tie-out tabs can also be included in the hot cutting/weld to hold all the fabric layers together.
The sewing of the first row of stitches is at a distance from the rolled edge that equals the desired width of the finished flat seam.
The seam can then be laid flat to sew the second line of stitches and the back-stitching of the tent tie-out tabs can be done without removal from under the sewing machine pressure foot.
To achieve the best lateral strength the flattened seam should be pulled tightly against the first line of stitches as the second line of stitches is made. This ensures that both lines of stitches bear the load equally. This is very appropriate for high-load and water-resistant tent seams.
Note: This seam that is formed this way is very similar to what people (including me) commonly call ‘lay-flat seam’. It should more correctly be called a Flat Felled Seam. It even has an ISO 4916 2.04.06 number. This number comes from this wonderful link that describes in detail most seams that seemingly one could dream up or have nightmares about. The seam that I describe with a welded start has one extra layer of fabric rolled within it (caused by the welded starting point). It just makes the seam a little stronger and plumper. The next seam that I describe does not have that extra layer and is a true Flat Felled Seam.
I find it somewhat ironic that most descriptions of making the Mock Felled Seam on YouTube start by sewing together the two layers with the edges flush (much like my welded start). They then faff around, cutting off an ‘unwanted’ strip of fabric and then roll and iron it before sewing the second line of stitches. This cut off strip could simply be left in place and rolled into the seam (as described above) making the seam stronger and simpler to sew.
Mock Felled Seam/Lay-flat seam (sic) with glue tacking instead of welding. This is straying away from hot cutting/welding. However, it was the forerunner to the cut/weld seam and it provides a context for the above seam sewing development. It is a near-equivalent seam when hot cut/welding is not available or suitable for a project.
My Mock Felled Seam is normally started in an unusual way. “This was taught to me by my dear and patient Mum who crafted magic at speed with a sewing machine. She also repaired many dead sewing machines wherever she visited. Having a professional sewing background she made every stitch count and did nothing that was not an improvement to strength, speed, economy or appearance. She was happy to share her skill and tricks with anyone who was interested.”
The seam starts by wrapping one edge tightly around the other and running the first line of stitches through the three layers of fabric at a distance from the rolled edge that will determine the subsequent seam width. This different approach immediately tames the stretch/creep problems if the wrapped edge happens to be bias cut fabric because (“Yes you guessed it!”) the bias cut fabric never touches the sewing machine feed dogs or pressure foot.
In other posts, Lay flat seams for pyramid tents, Glueing instead of pinning and Tie out tabs for pyramid tents I describe my evolution of tent seam forming that can easily integrated tie out tabs that start with glueing (instead of welding). They may also be of interest to you. l will let the following collage of photos tell the rest and possibly trigger your interest.
Back to the hot knife cutting
Welded bias grain stabilization tape. Selvedge offcuts abound when you make a tent with the use of a hot knife cutter. Many meters of it mound up. In my case, it had cosmetic defects (one hairy edge, little manufacturing pinholes and missing some silver coating. It otherwise makes a very strong and effective straight grain stabilization tape that has no fraying fibres.
It can be sewn onto the back of bias-cut edges to stop their stretching while sewing. It also plumps up the seam to four layers of fabric when the edge is rolled once. “Such seams are usually rolled to protect and hide cut edges. However, the rolling also seems to make the seam more resilient, but I can’t explain why.”
An example could be where a bias cut edge of the tent panel is to be sewn onto a long doorway zipper. The bias cut fabric can be laid flat in its unstretched state under or over the straight grain tape. With both nearly covered by a metal straight edge, a new edge can be cut/welded so that both are bonded together. “It wastes negligible fabric and eliminates the bias stretch and makes the next step of sewing to the zipper as easy as using a straight-grain edge.
Here is a little video of the hot knife cutter/welder.
Is hot cutting/welding a possible substitute for stitching?
Above I have described the simplest seam that can be prepared by hot cutting/welding, followed by simple sewing. The weld can be so strong that sewing may not be needed for some applications such as bags for backpacking cutlery, food, toiletries, backpacking fishing gear and rod covers etc (ie durable reusable substitutes for plastic bags).
I load tested some of my polyester that had been cut/welded. For the silly vain reason of having blue contrasting with silver in the photo, I placed the fabric so that a blue side faced a silver one. Partway through the welding, which took less than half a second, I thought; “Is that silver going to make the seal weaker?”
But it was too late to stop. So I tested the weld strength by hanging ~2,000g of water on it. I caught a couple of photos of it and was adjusting for the sun glare while thinking; “how much can it hold?” Then the weld failed.
Really quite strong, but I thought that putting the silver on the outside may leave a better weld.
The weld supported 2,000g and then 3,000g over some hours. “However, if you know me by now, I always like to find the breaking point and not be left wondering.” I loaded the weld up with 4,000g and just like the first test it held for `15 seconds then failed.
The bottom line to all this is that custom bags and covers could be made using this technique, particularly if backstitching was used to strengthen vulnerable points. However, sewing a simple seam is very easy after the welding so it may as well be done.
What fabrics can be welded together with a hot knife cutting?
I expect this list to grow as I go on tinkering, however, the photo below should show that there are endless possibilities.
Hot knife cutting/welding of dissimilar fabrics. With a background in thermoplastic heat sealing, I expected the hot knife cutter to work with all synthetic polymers when welded to themselves. I was less sure that the welding would work effectively when welding different polymers to each other.
My preliminary test strip shown above indicates that this is a viable option for popular technical fabrics and should be great assistance with DIY innovations. The Tyvek (polyethylene) was only able to be tack welded to itself and the polyethylene sheet, but not the woven polyethylene. The space blanket only tack welded to itself and PET and an uncoated polyester tent fabric. Just for fun, I put some 100 micron polyethylene sheet between two layers of shirt cotton fabric and the hot cutting formed a heat weld. All such welding should be viewed as a temporary tacking to prepare for easy sewing for long term strength.
Hot knife cutting/welding of silnylon fabric. I was unsure of what would happen to silnylon because of the properties of the silicone rubber component of the fabric. By my estimation and a more authoritative source, it will withstand a temperature of 205-300C. Anyway, it cuts and tack welds just fine. I just don’t know where the silicone rubber goes when the nylon melts and why the residual silicone rubber does not detrimentally contaminate and spoil the bonding of the melted nylon?
Hot knife cutting/welding of Noseeum netting. If you have used Noseeum netting in your DIY projects for adding windows/vents to tents, you would know how difficult it is to cut and sew precisely. It is so easily distorted and horrid to sew.
Imagine how easy such windows could be if the netting was first laid out flat under straight edges and was cut/welded to a strip of stable straight grain tent fabric to form a stable ‘frame’ around the window before sewing it to the tent?
After initial welding, the frame fabric can easily be rolled and sewn to the netting with a row of stitching. Then the frame can be sewn to the tent. “This is much easier than my previous glue/sew method, but will involve a bit of inside out thinking. Making and framing the window before cutting the hole in the tent always seems to be prudent!”
Other welding possibilities
Welding plastic bottles with a hot knife cutter. PET soft drink bottles and other plastic containers are a wonderful tinkering resource for us to make all sorts of things out of. “Cutting them with a hot knife cutter is like cutting butter with a warm knife that has just stabbed a hot scone. ” Reassembling the bottle into a useful thing can also be made easy with the same knife as a plastic welder, using the flat face of the blade. The example of a DIY tape storage jar in the photo below may help to explain the idea.
Hot scraping of adhering polymers from heat resistant surfaces
With my tinkering with hot tent stoves, I usually make my DIY protective stove jacks with various laminates of material to exploit their multiple virtuous properties such as heat resistance, water resistance, sewability, permanent glueability, and even temporary glueability that will allow peel off when needed.
When making these laminates it is simpler and less error-prone to put all the laminates together as a unit before cutting the precise elliptical hole for the stove pipe.
The core laminate of silicone rubber is the most heat resistant and can safely rest against the hot stove pipe. Other laminates such as silnylon or polyester need a little more clearance to ensure that they do not melt/burn during use.
The blade of the hot knife cutter can easily be used to hot scrape away some of the silnylon (or other synthetic fabric) from the silicone rubber to set the appropriate safe clearance. Peeling and cutting with scissors was almost impossible and left a horrible fraying mess. The hot scraping by contrast was easy, precise and left a neat sealed edge.
Hot knife cutting of thick-stuff
The above use of the knife has focused on delicate and thin materials, but the hot knife can easily handle really thick materials such as seatbelt webbing and tugboat lines and it leaves a neat finish. I just will let the video do the talking.
[Add a link to the tugboat rope and webbing cutting video.]
Hot knife cutting blade modification
The hot knife cutting tool arrived with the ‘arc-style’ blade. It performed really well but it was very sharp and it scored the sheet of metal that I used as backing support for the cutting. Consequently, I rounded the blade profile with the use of an aluminium oxide abrasive. This minimized the scoring, allowed the blade to move more freely and made it safer. Expect a post on an alternative customised blade some time.
Conclusion
Hot knife cutting is great for a DIY tinkerer. The cutting is fast and convenient and its fabric welding function can make difficult seam sewing easy.
Tim